Strict Liability vs. Negligence in Georgia Product Liability
Published 21 authorities named
Strict liability under § 51-1-11(b)(1) reaches only the manufacturer of a product sold as new, and the plaintiff needn’t prove carelessness in making it. Negligence reaches anyone in the chain who failed in a duty, and it has more exceptions to the ten-year repose. But for a design claim the two nearly merge. Banks v. ICI Americas, 264 Ga. 732 (1994), said of its own risk-utility test that “[c]onceptually and analytically, this approach bespeaks negligence”.
Side by side
| Issue | Strict liability, § 51-1-11(b)(1) | Negligence |
|---|---|---|
| Who | Manufacturer of property "sold as new" | Maker, seller, repairer, anyone with a duty |
| Plaintiff's core proof | Not merchantable or suited to its use, and that condition caused the injury | Duty, breach, causation, damages |
| Maker's care | Not the question in a manufacturing case | The question |
| Used goods | Not covered on that language | Possible, on the seller's own conduct |
| Ten-year repose | Applies under (b)(2), and (c)'s exceptions don't help | Applies under (c), with exceptions |
| Duty to warn once known | Not the route | Preserved by (c) |
| Fault of the plaintiff | Apportioned under Johns v. Suzuki | Apportioned |
| Punitive cap | None if the claim arises from product liability | Same, under Mack Trucks |
What strict liability actually requires
Center Chemical v. Parzini, 234 Ga. 868 (1975), says that “the claimant is not required to prove negligence”, but “the manufacturer is not an insurer”. “[N]ot merchantable and reasonably suited to the use intended” means the plaintiff must show that the product was defective when sold. “Fault” drops out only partly: the plaintiff still has to show a defect, and the maker’s care stays out of the manufacturing question.
The statute is construed narrowly. As Alltrade v. McDonald, 213 Ga. App. 758 (1994), says, it “must be strictly construed”. Sellers don’t fall within it under § 51-1-11.1, as manufacturer versus seller explains. A “sale” can include a trial placement of a product, under Robert F. Bullock, Inc. v. Thorpe, 256 Ga. 744 (1987), and the claim runs “irrespective of privity”, so a bystander reasonably affected can sue.
Design: where the theories converge
Banks explained that a jury using risk-utility is saying the manufacturer’s choice “exposed the consumer to greater risk of danger than he should have”. The same test governs design claims under both labels, as Ogletree v. Navistar, 269 Ga. 443 (1998), shows: it found no justification for the open and obvious rule in design cases “whether brought in strict liability or in negligence”. In CertainTeed v. Fletcher, 300 Ga. 327 (2016), Banks governed a negligent design claim. Risk-utility sets out the factors.
So pleading both in a design case may add less than it seems at the proof stage, and the difference shows up at the edges: who can be sued, and which repose rule applies.
Warnings
Warning claims can run in negligence. Chrysler v. Batten, 264 Ga. 723 (1994), treats a negligence case as two claims: selling a defective product and failing to warn. The duty “arises whenever the manufacturer knows or reasonably should know of the danger”. Batten also holds that § 51-1-11(c) “carefully excluded failure-to-warn causes of action” from the repose. Parzini’s reference to inadequate warnings under the strict liability statute keeps a strict liability route open in theory, though PTI Royston v. Eubanks, 360 Ga. App. 263 (2021), held a strict liability warning count barred by repose, leaving the negligence claims. See failure to warn.
Why the difference matters after ten years
| Facts | Strict liability | Negligence |
|---|---|---|
| Product more than ten years from first sale, ordinary injury | Barred | Barred, for design and manufacture |
| Same, with reckless conduct | Barred | Exception applies, under Ford v. Cosper |
| Same, with a failure to warn | Barred under PTI Royston's reasoning | Survives, under Batten |
| Disease caused by a negligently made product | Barred | Exception applies |
The ten-year repose and its exceptions set this out. A person with a very old product may have only the negligence route.
Defenses by theory
| Defense | Strict liability | Negligence |
|---|---|---|
| Plaintiff's fault | Reduces recovery, and bars at 50 percent, under § 51-12-33 and Johns | Same |
| Assumption of risk | Requires actual knowledge, as in Bodymasters | Same |
| Unforeseeable misuse | Product isn't defective, under Woods | No duty |
| Third-party alteration | No causation, under Talley | Same |
| Compliance with standards | Doesn't "eliminate conclusively" liability, under Banks | Same |
| Maker's reasonable care | Not a defense to manufacturing defect | Goes to breach |
Comparative negligence goes through these.
Punitive damages and the label
The label isn’t what removes the cap. In Mack Trucks v. Conkle, 263 Ga. 539 (1993), the jury found negligent failure to recall or warn and rejected strict liability. The Supreme Court still treated it as a product liability action, so the $250,000 limit in § 51-12-5.1(g) didn’t apply. The evidentiary standard remains clear and convincing evidence under (b).
Warranty is separate
An implied warranty claim needs privity or a family or household connection, under § 11-2-318. In Bryant v. Hoffmann-La Roche, 262 Ga. App. 401 (2003), a patient wasn’t covered. In Bodymasters v. Wimberley, 232 Ga. App. 170 (1998), a gym member wasn’t either. So warranty may not replace these two theories for someone who didn’t buy the product.
What to plead
- Strict liability against each company that actually made the product or part, if the first sale is within ten years.
- Negligent design and manufacture, for the wider defendant list and the exceptions.
- Negligent failure to warn, including after sale.
- The seller’s own negligence, only on real facts.
- Punitive damages, which must be “specifically prayed for” under § 51-12-5.1(d)(1).
Each count should have evidence behind it by summary judgment. A theory that is merely available won’t carry a case. As Sheffield v. Conair, 348 Ga. App. 6 (2018), shows, without proof of the design’s risks and how they could have been avoided, both theories fail together.
Sources
- Banks v. ICI Americas, 264 Ga. 732
- Center Chemical v. Parzini, 234 Ga. 868
- Alltrade v. McDonald, 213 Ga. App. 758
- Robert F. Bullock, Inc. v. Thorpe, 256 Ga. 744
- Ogletree v. Navistar, 269 Ga. 443
- CertainTeed v. Fletcher, 300 Ga. 327
- Chrysler v. Batten, 264 Ga. 723
- PTI Royston v. Eubanks, 360 Ga. App. 263
- Ford v. Cosper, 317 Ga. 356
- Johns v. Suzuki Motor of America, 310 Ga. 159
- Bodymasters v. Wimberley, 232 Ga. App. 170
- Woods v. A.R.E. Accessories, A18A0292
- Talley v. City Tank, 158 Ga. App. 130
- Mack Trucks v. Conkle, 263 Ga. 539
- Bryant v. Hoffmann-La Roche, 262 Ga. App. 401
- Sheffield v. Conair, 348 Ga. App. 6
- Official Code of Georgia Annotated, November 2022 public release: §§ 11-2-318, 51-1-11, 51-1-11.1, 51-12-5.1, 51-12-33
This page was last reviewed in November 2026 for general information. Laws and court decisions can change after that date. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
More on: Defective product
- Defective Medical Device Cases in Georgia
- Filing a Product Liability Lawsuit in Georgia: Procedural Steps
- Industrial Equipment and Workplace Product Liability
- Product Liability Claims in Georgia: An Overview
- Failure to Warn Claims in Georgia Product Liability
- Comparative Negligence in Georgia Product Liability Cases
Authorities cited
Georgia code
- O.C.G.A. § 51-1-11
- O.C.G.A. § 51-1-11.1
- O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33
- O.C.G.A. § 51-12-5.1
- O.C.G.A. § 11-2-318
Court decisions
- Banks v. ICI Americas, 264 Ga. 732
- Center Chemical v. Parzini, 234 Ga. 868
- Alltrade v. McDonald, 213 Ga. App. 758
- Robert F. Bullock, Inc. v. Thorpe, 256 Ga. 744
- Ogletree v. Navistar, 269 Ga. 443
- CertainTeed v. Fletcher, 300 Ga. 327
- Chrysler v. Batten, 264 Ga. 723
- PTI Royston v. Eubanks, 360 Ga. App. 263
- Ford v. Cosper, 317 Ga. 356
- Johns v. Suzuki Motor of America, 310 Ga. 159
- Bodymasters v. Wimberley, 232 Ga. App. 170
- Woods v. A.R.E. Accessories, A18A0292
- Talley v. City Tank, 158 Ga. App. 130
- Mack Trucks v. Conkle, 263 Ga. 539
- Bryant v. Hoffmann-La Roche, 262 Ga. App. 401
- Sheffield v. Conair, 348 Ga. App. 6
Leave a Reply