Skip to the articles
Attorney Directory

Punitive Damages in Georgia Product Liability (No Cap + 75% State Share)

Published 5 authorities named

In a Georgia product liability case, § 51-12-5.1(e)(1) removes any limit on punitive damages, and § 51-12-5.1(e)(2) sends 75 percent of the award to the state, less a proportionate part of costs and attorney’s fees. The same subsection allows only one award against a defendant for an act or omission. The standard for getting any award at all stays high: clear and convincing evidence under subsection (b).

How product cases differ

Type of tort Limit State share Provision
Arises from product liability None 75 percent, less costs and fees (e)
Specific intent to harm, or impaired by alcohol or drugs, not a product case None Not in the text of (f) (f)
Every other tort $250,000 Not in the text of (g) (g)

In Taylor v. Devereux Foundation, 316 Ga. 44 (2023), the Supreme Court of Georgia upheld the $250,000 limit in a premises case. It doesn’t reach a product claim, which subsection (e) handles separately. Subsection (f) opens with the words “[i]n a tort case in which the cause of action does not arise from product liability”, so it isn’t a second route for a product claim, whatever the facts.

Which cases “arise from product liability”

Mack Trucks v. Conkle, 263 Ga. 539 (1993), answered an important part of that. The jury found Mack liable for negligent failure to recall or warn, and it rejected strict liability. The Supreme Court still held that a negligence-based product suit counts as product liability, so the $250,000 limit didn’t apply. It also rejected an equal protection attack on the state’s share, because “all similarly situated plaintiffs and defendants, including those in product liability actions, are treated equally by the statute”.

The standard of proof

The evidence must be clear and convincing, and it must show “willful misconduct, malice, fraud, wantonness, oppression, or that entire want of care which would raise the presumption of conscious indifference to consequences”. Negligence alone doesn’t reach this.

Evidence Why it helped Decision
Engineers reported an inadequate frame for four years Knowledge over time Mack Trucks
Marketing vetoed a $103 strengthening in 1984 and 1987 A choice on known risk Mack Trucks
No notice to buyers Inaction after knowing Mack Trucks
Other trucks with similar cracks Notice, once "substantially similar" Mack Trucks

Compliance doesn’t necessarily protect a maker on this question, though it’s evidence. In Chrysler v. Walden, 303 Ga. 358 (2018), the company showed federal compliance and the agency’s final view, yet a jury found reckless or wanton conduct for repose purposes. That wasn’t a punitive award, so don’t read it as a holding about one.

The trial sequence

Punitive damages must be “specifically prayed for in a complaint”, under (d)(1). The jury first decides whether to award them, in a special verdict finding. If yes, the trial “shall immediately be recommenced” on the amount, under (d)(2), with evidence on what will deter, penalize, or punish. Ask how that interacts with phased trial elections under § 51-12-15, which SB 68 added in 2025.

The 75 percent share

Read (e)(2) closely.

Text What it means
"Seventy-five percent of any amounts awarded under this subsection" Applies to the (e) award
"less a proportionate part of the costs of litigation, including reasonable attorney's fees" The state bears its share of costs and fees
"all as determined by the trial judge" The judge sets those numbers
State has "all rights due a judgment creditor" It can enforce
"equal footing with the plaintiff" after "damages awarded other than as punitive damages" Compensatory damages get paid first
Debtor "may remit" to the clerk, who pays over "within 60 days of receipt" The mechanics of payment
Not "a party at interest" The state's right is only to proceeds

The statute doesn’t spell out a formula, so ask counsel how a court would run the arithmetic. The point is that the plaintiff doesn’t simply keep a quarter, and the state doesn’t simply take three quarters. A contingency fee contract should address this as well.

Settlement before verdict raises a different question. The state’s share is tied to amounts “awarded”. Whether a given settlement allocation is affected is something to ask a lawyer about.

The one-award rule

“Only one award of punitive damages may be recovered in a court in this state from a defendant for any act or omission if the cause of action arises from product liability, regardless of the number of causes of action which may arise from such act or omission.”

This has practical force for a mass-market product. The statute’s text speaks of one award per act or omission. It doesn’t say how to define the act, or how the first award affects a later plaintiff if the conduct continued. Check whether another Georgia award has already been made against the same defendant on the same conduct, and ask counsel how the facts differ. Awards in other states aren’t covered by the words “in a court in this state”.

In death cases

Punitive damages don’t run with every wrongful death theory. Punitive damages in wrongful death cases has the rule, and the claim comes through the estate. The product limit and state share above apply if the claim arises from product liability.

Choosing the theory

Question Why it matters
Is this really a product claim? Decides between (e) and the $250,000 limit
Who made the choice, and when? Punitive conduct is the defendant's own
Is there a seller's own bad conduct? Consider the facts and the statute's phrase
Is the evidence in documents? Clear and convincing proof may depend on them
Is a federal defense in play? Preemption can remove a claim first

Federal preemption explains that last row. The statute applies to causes of action arising on or after April 14, 1997, under (h). Reckless conduct can also defeat the repose on negligence claims, and that’s a separate test, defined in Ford v. Cosper, as the repose exceptions explains. Don’t treat a finding on one as proof of the other.

Damages in product cases covers everything else that can be recovered.

Sources

This page was last reviewed in November 2026 for general information. Laws and court decisions can change after that date. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

More on: Defective product

Authorities cited

Georgia code

  • O.C.G.A. § 51-12-5.1
  • O.C.G.A. § 51-12-15

Court decisions

  • Taylor v. Devereux Foundation, 316 Ga. 44
  • Mack Trucks v. Conkle, 263 Ga. 539
  • Chrysler v. Walden, 303 Ga. 358

Every source, with its link

Reader comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *