Comparative Negligence in Georgia Product Liability Cases
Published 16 authorities named
Georgia’s comparative fault statute applies to product liability cases, including strict liability. Johns v. Suzuki Motor of America, 310 Ga. 159 (2020), so held, on a jury’s finding that a rider was 49 percent at fault for not changing his brake fluid in eight years. Recovery is reduced by the plaintiff’s share and ends at 50 percent or more. Yet misuse and assumption of risk can have a larger effect, because they can defeat the claim altogether.
Four different defenses
They look alike, but they work differently.
| Defense | What it asks | Effect | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comparative fault | Did the plaintiff's carelessness contribute? | Reduces recovery, ending at 50 percent | Johns |
| Assumption of risk | Did the person actually know of and accept this danger? | Can bar the claim | Bodymasters; Dean |
| Unforeseeable misuse | Was this use beyond what the maker had to anticipate? | Product isn't defective | Woods |
| Third-party alteration | Did someone replace the design? | No causation | Talley |
Fault of a non-party is a fifth point, below.
What Johns decided
The motorcycle’s brakes failed, and the jury found for the plaintiffs on all claims, with the rider at 49 percent. The trial court cut $10.5 million to $5,355,000. The Supreme Court held that § 51-12-33(a) reaches strict product liability claims.
The opinion also explains what the older case law allowed. A jury could consider a plaintiff’s conduct “if it went beyond merely failing to discover the product’s defect or to guard against the possibility of its existence and instead constituted a knowing assumption of the risk”. That earlier line doesn’t vanish, and it helps a plaintiff frame what fault means: a person who simply failed to spot a hidden defect isn’t an easy target. Whether a given act is fault under § 51-12-33 is still for the jury.
Assumption of risk needs actual knowledge
| Decision | Facts | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Bodymasters v. Wimberley (1998) | Gym user knew the leg press had no stop | Jury question |
| Dean v. Toyota Industrial (2000) | Worker hit by a forklift, said to know of the danger | Jury question |
| Bodymasters (warning count) | She knew wet shoes could slip and wiped them | No proximate cause on warning |
“A defect and the danger arising from it are not necessarily to be identified”, said Bodymasters v. Wimberley, 232 Ga. App. 170 (1998). Dean v. Toyota Industrial Equipment, 246 Ga. App. 255 (2000), says a person “must comprehend and appreciate the nature of the danger he confronts”. So knowing that a machine has no alarm isn’t the same as appreciating what could happen. These decisions predate Johns on how the theories overlap, so counsel should read them together.
Misuse: foreseeable or not
“[A] product manufacturer has no duty to design or warn against harm caused by an unforeseeable misuse of its product”, said Woods v. A.R.E. Accessories, A18A0292 (2018). A firefighter’s pickup got a custom sliding bed that struck a gas strut on a truck cap’s door, and the door fell on his head. Nothing showed the cap’s maker could have foreseen that. The misuse was “the sole cause”.
Foreseeable misuse is another matter, since it’s “a factor” in the design balance. Wording matters here. The statute speaks of property not “reasonably suited to the use intended”, and it protects anyone who “may use, consume, or reasonably be affected by the property”. In Jones v. NordicTrack, 274 Ga. 115 (2001), a person walking through a room could sue, so use isn’t required.
Ask these questions.
| Question | Why |
|---|---|
| Did the maker's instructions cover this? | Goes to foreseeability and warnings |
| Do others use it this way? | Goes to foreseeability |
| Did the design invite it? | Goes to the risk-utility balance |
| Did the maker know? | Complaints, if they meet the similarity gate |
Alterations after sale
In Talley v. City Tank, 158 Ga. App. 130 (1981), a city rebuilt a garbage truck’s lifting system, and a worker was killed. Injuries “cannot be traced to or be the proximate result of the manufacturer’s original design which did not exist at the time of injury”. A slight change may still be a jury question, as Talley notes. In Yamaha v. Hall, A26A0228 (2026), a modified golf cart’s modification defense was left for retrial. So a person who bought used needs the product’s history.
Obvious dangers
In a design case, obviousness is a factor, not a bar, under Ogletree v. Navistar, 269 Ga. 443 (1998). A rule from before Ogletree doesn’t control design cases now, so check the date of any decision cited to you. On a warning claim, the court left the question open, and Bodymasters shows that known danger can end that count on causation.
Other people’s fault
Section 51-12-33 can also reach non-parties. That’s where a product case gets complicated.
| Who | Basis | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Immune employer | Walker v. Tensor Machinery | Share counts, though the employer doesn't pay |
| Another driver | Apportionment, with Polston on enhanced injury | Share reduces the maker's |
| Repair shop | Negligent maintenance | As in Mack Trucks, a separate share |
| Parent of a child | Ask counsel | Gregory left parents' negligence for the jury in a premises case |
Walker v. Tensor Machinery, 298 Ga. 297 (2015), says that immunity doesn’t stop a jury from assessing a percentage against an employer. Zaldivar sets the test for a non-party. The 50 percent rule explains the base statute.
What the defense will look for
- Maintenance records, as with the brake fluid in Johns
- Whether instructions were read and followed
- Modifications and non-original parts
- Prior incidents with the same product
- Training, experience, and license
- Alcohol or drugs
- Whether a guard or safety feature was disabled
Answer these early, and accurately. A manual may show what the maker told users, and a failure to follow it can go either way: fault, or evidence that the warning was buried. In Wilson Foods v. Turner, 218 Ga. App. 74 (1995), a user who didn’t read a warning couldn’t challenge its content, but “[f]ailure to read a warning does not bar recovery when the plaintiff is challenging the adequacy of the efforts” to communicate the danger.
Time limits are separate from all this. Two years under § 9-3-33, and the ten-year repose in § 51-1-11(b)(2).
Sources
- Johns v. Suzuki Motor of America, 310 Ga. 159
- Bodymasters v. Wimberley, 232 Ga. App. 170
- Dean v. Toyota Industrial Equipment, 246 Ga. App. 255
- Woods v. A.R.E. Accessories, A18A0292
- Jones v. NordicTrack, 274 Ga. 115
- Talley v. City Tank, 158 Ga. App. 130
- Yamaha v. Hall, A26A0228
- Ogletree v. Navistar, 269 Ga. 443
- Walker v. Tensor Machinery, 298 Ga. 297
- Polston v. Boomershine Pontiac-GMC, 262 Ga. 616
- Mack Trucks v. Conkle, 263 Ga. 539
- Gregory v. Johnson, 249 Ga. 151
- Wilson Foods v. Turner, 218 Ga. App. 74
- Official Code of Georgia Annotated, November 2022 public release: §§ 9-3-33, 51-1-11, 51-12-33
This page was last reviewed in November 2026 for general information. Laws and court decisions can change after that date. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
More on: Defective product
- Defective Medical Device Cases in Georgia
- Filing a Product Liability Lawsuit in Georgia: Procedural Steps
- Industrial Equipment and Workplace Product Liability
- Product Liability Claims in Georgia: An Overview
- Failure to Warn Claims in Georgia Product Liability
- Damages Available in Georgia Product Liability Cases
Authorities cited
Georgia code
- O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33
- O.C.G.A. § 9-3-33
- O.C.G.A. § 51-1-11
Court decisions
- Johns v. Suzuki Motor of America, 310 Ga. 159
- Bodymasters v. Wimberley, 232 Ga. App. 170
- Dean v. Toyota Industrial Equipment, 246 Ga. App. 255
- Woods v. A.R.E. Accessories, A18A0292
- Jones v. NordicTrack, 274 Ga. 115
- Talley v. City Tank, 158 Ga. App. 130
- Yamaha v. Hall, A26A0228
- Ogletree v. Navistar, 269 Ga. 443
- Walker v. Tensor Machinery, 298 Ga. 297
- Polston v. Boomershine Pontiac-GMC, 262 Ga. 616
- Mack Trucks v. Conkle, 263 Ga. 539
- Gregory v. Johnson, 249 Ga. 151
- Wilson Foods v. Turner, 218 Ga. App. 74
Leave a Reply