Settlement Negotiations During Litigation in Georgia
Published 11 authorities named
Once a Georgia injury suit is filed, settlement talks continue, but they now carry a fee-shifting tool: the offer of settlement under § 9-11-68. Reject a defendant’s offer, finish below 75 percent of it, and you can owe that side’s attorney’s fees from the date of rejection. A plaintiff’s offer works in reverse at 125 percent. So every written number in a lawsuit needs one more question. Is this a talking point, or is it a statutory offer with a clock?
How a § 9-11-68 offer works
| Element | Rule | Subsection |
|---|---|---|
| Earliest date | More than 30 days after service of the summons and complaint | (a) |
| Latest date | At least 30 days before trial, or 20 days for a counteroffer | (a) |
| Filing | Served, but not filed with the court | (a) |
| Claim type | A tort claim, for money | (a) |
| Form | Writing that names the statute, parties, claims, conditions, total amount, punitive amount, and fee treatment | (a)(1) to (7) |
| Service | Certificate of service, by certified mail or statutory overnight delivery | (a)(8) |
| Defendant's offer rejected | Fees if there's no liability or the judgment is under 75 percent of the offer | (b)(1) |
| Plaintiff's offer rejected | Fees if the judgment is greater than 125 percent of the offer | (b)(2) |
| Open period | 30 days, unless withdrawn in writing before acceptance | (c) |
| Withdrawn early | No fees to the extent the offer wasn't open for 30 days, unless rejected in that period | (c) |
| Bad faith | A court may disallow the fees if an offer wasn't made in good faith | (d)(2) |
Each requirement has to be met, so a letter that merely mentions a settlement figure isn’t an offer under the statute. Use the eight items in (a) as a checklist, and ask counsel to review any offer you get right away, since the date matters.
The math in plain numbers
For example, imagine a defendant serves a $100,000 offer. By the statute, 75 percent of that is $75,000. If the plaintiff rejects it and later gets a judgment under $75,000, or loses, the defendant can seek reasonable fees and expenses from the rejection date through the judgment.
Now imagine a plaintiff serves a $100,000 offer. The trigger is more than 125 percent, which is above $125,000. If a judgment clears that line, the plaintiff can seek fees from the date of rejection.
The comparison depends on the final judgment. Apportionment under § 51-12-33 can lower the amount a defendant owes, so a strong damages number may still fall under the line after fault is divided. Think about that before rejecting.
The offer can’t reach back to cases filed before the law existed. In Fowler Properties v. Dowland, 282 Ga. 76 (2007), the Supreme Court of Georgia treated the fee obligation as substantive and rejected its retroactive use in a pending case. That doesn’t help a case filed today, but it shows the court sees the risk as a real financial duty.
Other money pressure
| Tool | How it works | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Interest on a demand, § 51-12-14 | Written notice naming the statute, by listed delivery, with 30 days to pay; interest if the judgment reaches the demand | Check the rate in (c) |
| Fees for bad faith or stubborn litigiousness, § 13-6-11 | Must be specially pleaded, and a jury decides | Needs its own proof |
| Frivolous positions, § 9-11-68(e) | A separate hearing after verdict, on motion | Its own standard |
| Excess exposure | A carrier's refusal of a within-limits chance may matter later | Needs its own analysis |
Fee awards now have a separate limit. Under § 9-15-16, added by Senate Bill 68, no party can recover the same fees, costs, or expenses more than once unless a statute specifically authorizes it, and a contingent fee agreement “shall not be admissible as proof of the reasonableness of the fees”. That second limit is narrow. In Cayamcela v. Advocacy Trust, S26A0229 (2026), the Supreme Court of Georgia said nothing in the section stops a court from considering the agreement for other purposes, like total fees incurred. It affirmed about $11.8 million in fees under § 9-11-68 after a rejected $3 million offer, where reasonableness was shown through testimony and a detailed chart of the work.
Bad faith and the Holt doctrine covers that last row. The statutory offer and the interest demand aren’t the same paper. Serve each with its own requirements in mind.
Settlement talk stays out as proof of liability or amount under § 24-4-408, and § 24-4-408(a) carves out § 9-11-68 for its own use. So the fee motion can refer to the offer even though a jury won’t hear about it.
Deals that aren’t a simple check
- Policy limits with a limited release. Section 33-24-41.1 may let you settle with one carrier and go on against other coverage. See settlement documentation.
- Partial settlements. The settling party’s fault may still count under § 51-12-33(d)(1), so price it in.
- High-low agreements. The sides agree on a floor and a ceiling before a verdict. They remove risk both ways, and they need to be in writing, including who’s told about them.
- A settling defendant who stays in the case. An arrangement of that kind can raise fairness and disclosure problems, so counsel should look at current Georgia law before using one.
- Structured payments. Part of the amount may be paid over time; see structured settlements.
- Multiple plaintiffs. One policy, several claimants. Each person needs to understand the split, and their lawyer may have a conflict to address.
Who has to say yes
A lawsuit can have more decision-makers than a pre-suit claim: a claims handler, a supervisor, defense counsel, and sometimes an excess carrier. Ask who has authority, and whether an excess insurer has been told. A lawyer’s written agreement can bind you under § 15-19-5, so settle your limits with your lawyer first. In a child’s case, § 29-3-3 sets its own approval steps, and an estate may need its own authority.
Taxes in the conversation
Under 26 U.S.C. § 104(a)(2), damages “other than punitive damages” on account of personal physical injuries are excluded from income. Interest and punitive amounts stand differently. So an offer that specifies a punitive amount under § 9-11-68(a)(6) deserves a tax question.
When to raise a number
Depositions, expert rulings, a summary judgment decision, or a mediation date can each reset both sides’ view. Mediation during litigation lays out those moments. Before responding to anything, have current lien figures, your costs so far, and the costs still to come. Compare offers by what you’d take home, not by the headline figure.
Sources
- Fowler Properties v. Dowland, 282 Ga. 76
- 26 U.S.C. § 104
- Official Code of Georgia Annotated, November 2022 public release: §§ 9-11-68, 13-6-11, 15-19-5, 24-4-408, 29-3-3, 33-24-41.1, 51-12-14, 51-12-33
- Georgia Senate Bill 68 (2025): § 9-15-16
- Cayamcela v. Advocacy Trust, S26A0229 (2026)
This page was last reviewed in November 2026 for general information. Laws and court decisions can change after that date. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Authorities cited
Georgia code
- O.C.G.A. § 9-11-68
- O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33
- O.C.G.A. § 51-12-14
- O.C.G.A. § 13-6-11
- O.C.G.A. § 9-15-16
- O.C.G.A. § 24-4-408
- O.C.G.A. § 15-19-5
- O.C.G.A. § 29-3-3
- O.C.G.A. § 33-24-41.1
Court decisions
- Fowler Properties v. Dowland, 282 Ga. 76
- Cayamcela v. Advocacy Trust, S26A0229
Leave a Reply