Life Care Plans in Georgia Traumatic Brain Injury Cases
Published 9 authorities named
A life care plan in a Georgia brain injury case is an expert’s itemized list of the care a person will need for life, with a frequency, a duration, and a price for each item. It’s evidence, not a measure of damages by itself. A plan holds up only as far as a physician supports the need, so it’s built on the medical record and tested under § 24-7-702 like any other expert work. Georgia doesn’t require a particular credential by statute.
What a sound plan looks like
| Column | Example | Weak if |
|---|---|---|
| Item | Neuropsychology follow-up | Generic list copied from another case |
| Who supports it | Treating physiatrist | No doctor named |
| Frequency | Per the doctor's schedule | Just "as needed" |
| Duration | Fixed period or for life | Lifetime for a short-term need |
| Unit price | Local vendor or agency quote | No source |
| Replacement | Equipment service life | Unsupported cycles |
The items may include physician care, therapy, medication, equipment, supervision or attendant care, home or vehicle changes, and case management. Whether each belongs depends on the patient. Attendant care can dominate a plan because it recurs every day, so it deserves the closest support.
The physician link
The law’s requirement of certainty applies to each line. In Womack v. Burgess, 200 Ga. App. 347 (1991), medication the doctor said was needed went to the jury, and a 50/50 surgery didn’t. So if a plan contains a future surgery, ask the surgeon how likely it is. Section 51-12-8 keeps out “the imaginary or possible result” of a wrong.
A planner shouldn’t be the only source of medical opinion. A sounder approach:
- Review the records.
- Interview the patient and family, and visit the home if possible.
- Send proposed recommendations to a treating or retained physician.
- Revise after that review, and keep the correspondence.
- Update when the condition changes.
The gate: § 24-7-702
A planner testifies as an expert, as does the physician and the economist. Expert disclosures explains the rule. Questions a court may ask:
- Qualifications. What’s this person’s training in this kind of care? A certification may help the credibility argument, but the statute asks about knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education.
- Method. Is it consistent, and can it be repeated?
- Fit. Does it rest on this patient’s facts, and on opinions that are in the record?
The result in Stubbs v. Home Depot, A26A0824 (2026), though in a product case, shows the trial court’s discretion on experience: an automobile mechanic was excluded on a mower engine. Choose accordingly.
How the 2025 law touches the plan
Section 51-12-1.1(f) lets either side challenge “projected future expenses”. Under (c), if the person has health insurance, evidence of value “shall include both the amounts charged for past, present, or future” expenses and “the amounts actually necessary to satisfy such charges”. It applies “regardless of whether the health insurance has been used, is used, or will be used”. So a plan priced only at retail is open to attack in a newer case. A plan should say which prices it used, and why. Future medical expenses discusses the rule.
Turning a plan into a number
A plan’s lifetime total isn’t what a jury has to award. The economist works with it.
| Input | Source | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Annual cost by item | Plan | Check the addition |
| Length of life | Physician; § 24-14-45 tables | Tables admissible, not exclusive |
| Cost growth | Economist | Assumption, so state it |
| Discount | § 51-12-13(a) | 5 percent "or any other discount rate" |
| Item-specific end dates | Plan | Don't discount items that stop |
Under § 51-12-13(b), the price of a specific annuity doesn’t come in as evidence on this point. Keep lifetime and present value clearly labeled for the jury.
How defense plans attack
The defense may hire its own planner, or simply cross-examine line by line.
| Target | Their point | What to have ready |
|---|---|---|
| Attendant hours | Fewer hours or lower skill | Functional assessment, daily log |
| Institutional or home | Facility costs less | Doctor's reasoning, patient's needs |
| Duplicates | Same service twice | Clean categories |
| Cost source | Too high | Quotes, dated |
| Use | Not actually using it | Why, such as cost or access |
| Life expectancy | Shorter | Physician's reasons |
Non-use needs an honest answer. A person who has no money for therapy isn’t refusing it. A person who declines recommended care raises a different point. Be ready for § 51-11-7 and mitigation arguments.
Timing
A plan written too early will change, and one written too late may run into a scheduling order. Have counsel plan around the stable point of recovery, which may come after the two-year limit forces a filing under § 9-3-33. Children raise extra questions, since needs change as they grow. Update the plan through trial.
Using it in settlement
A plan may also shape how money is arranged after settlement. It’s a useful basis for a structured settlement, because payments can track projected needs. It doesn’t guarantee what an insurer will pay. Coverage limits, fault shares, and liens all affect the result, as severe TBI damages explains.
Sources
- Womack v. Burgess, 200 Ga. App. 347
- Stubbs v. Home Depot, A26A0824
- Official Code of Georgia Annotated, November 2022 public release: §§ 9-3-33, 24-7-702, 24-14-45, 51-11-7, 51-12-8, 51-12-13
- Georgia Senate Bill 68 (2025): § 51-12-1.1
This page was last reviewed in November 2026 for general information. Laws and court decisions can change after that date. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
More on: Catastrophic injury
Authorities cited
Georgia code
- O.C.G.A. § 24-7-702
- O.C.G.A. § 24-14-45
- O.C.G.A. § 51-12-13
- O.C.G.A. § 51-11-7
- O.C.G.A. § 9-3-33
- O.C.G.A. § 51-12-8
- O.C.G.A. § 51-12-1.1
Court decisions
- Womack v. Burgess, 200 Ga. App. 347
- Stubbs v. Home Depot, A26A0824
Leave a Reply