Independent Medical Examinations in Georgia Personal Injury Cases
Published 4 authorities named
An “independent medical examination” in a Georgia injury case is an exam by a doctor the other side selects, and in a filed lawsuit § 9-11-35 controls it. The court can order one when a party’s physical or mental condition “is in controversy”, but only “on motion for good cause shown”. The name is a label. It isn’t a statement about the doctor, and the examining doctor doesn’t treat you. An insurer’s request before suit is a different thing from a court order.
What § 9-11-35 requires
| Element | Rule | Subsection |
|---|---|---|
| Condition at issue | "[I]n controversy" | (a) |
| Showing | Motion, good cause, and notice to the person and all parties | (a) |
| Who may examine, physical | "[A] physician" | (a) |
| Who may examine, mental | "[A] physician or a licensed psychologist" | (a) |
| What the order states | "[T]ime, place, manner, conditions, and scope", and the examiner | (a) |
| Report, on request | A detailed written report with findings, test results, diagnoses, and conclusions | (b)(1) |
| Earlier reports | Reports of like exams of the same condition | (b)(1) |
| Reports the other way | The examining party may receive your reports on the condition | (b)(2) |
| Non-compliance | Exclusion of an examiner's testimony if no report is made | (b)(3) |
| Privilege cost | Asking for the report can waive privilege | (b)(4) |
Before suit is filed
No court order exists yet. So the question is why you’d be asked, and by whom.
- Your own insurer. A medical payments, uninsured motorist, or disability claim may rest on a policy clause about exams. Read the policy, since refusing may affect that coverage.
- The other driver’s insurer. It has no contract with you. Its request may matter for negotiation, but it isn’t a court order under § 9-11-35.
- Workers’ compensation. That system has its own exam rules, so don’t assume this page describes them. See coordinating a third-party settlement with workers’ compensation for how the two systems overlap.
Get advice before agreeing, because agreed terms replace what a court would have set.
Where the terms can be argued
The statute lets a court set the “manner, conditions, and scope”, which means that those items can be argued over. Section 9-11-35 itself doesn’t list a rule on recording, a companion, or the length of the exam. So a request for a recording or an observer goes to the judge in that case, and your lawyer can check for appellate rulings on the point.
| Item to raise | Why |
|---|---|
| Which body parts and conditions | Scope ties to what's in controversy |
| Which tests | Invasive or painful tests deserve a specific request |
| How far you'd travel | Cost and burden |
| Who pays for travel or lost time | Ask, because the statute's text doesn't say |
| Forms the clinic wants signed | Check first; authorization forms may reach further than the order |
| Recording or an observer | Ask the court, with reasons |
Refusing to go after an order is a poor option, since § 9-11-37(b)(2) sanctions can follow. Section 9-11-37(b)(2)(D) treats exam orders differently from other orders by excluding contempt, but the other sanctions remain.
The report and the waiver
Under (b)(1), the person examined can ask for a copy of the report, and the examining side must then deliver it. That can be valuable. But (b)(4) carries a cost: “[b]y requesting and obtaining a report of the examination so ordered or by taking the deposition of the examiner”, the person waives “any privilege he may have” in that action or a related one about “the testimony of every other person who has examined or may thereafter examine him” on that condition. So talk to your lawyer before asking, especially if a psychologist or psychiatrist has treated you. See medical records on mental health privilege.
The waiver rule cuts toward a practical step too. Reports on the condition can flow to the defense under (b)(2), so assume that reports about that condition may be seen.
How to approach the exam itself
The doctor isn’t there to treat you, so normal doctor-patient expectations don’t transfer.
- Arrive on time, and bring a list of your medications if you’ve been asked to.
- Answer honestly about how the injury happened and what hurts. Be accurate about earlier problems, since records will show them.
- Describe your actual limits. Don’t overstate them, and don’t downplay them to be polite.
- Remember that observation can start in the parking lot and the waiting room.
- Afterward, write down how long the doctor spent, what was tested, and what was said while it’s fresh.
Don’t sign unfamiliar forms on the spot. Tell your lawyer what you’ve been asked to sign.
Responding to the report
Reports are opinions, and a report isn’t a finding of fact. A defense doctor’s conclusion can be tested at a deposition and under § 24-7-702, the standard covered in expert disclosures and Daubert.
| Question to test | Compare with |
|---|---|
| How long was the exam? | Your notes |
| Which records did the doctor review? | The treating file and the list in the report |
| What's the doctor's practice? | Testimony history and income from this work, where discovery allows it |
| Does the doctor attribute symptoms to a prior condition? | Earlier records |
| Does the doctor rely on a surveillance clip? | The full video |
Defenses based on a pre-existing condition and surveillance video each raise their own questions. A report can also help. If the defense’s own doctor accepts an injury, a surgery, or a work limit, that narrows the dispute. And a treating doctor’s response can come through testimony or a narrative under § 24-8-826, on the notice that section requires.
Sources
- Official Code of Georgia Annotated, November 2022 public release: §§ 9-11-35, 9-11-37, 24-7-702, 24-8-826
This page was last reviewed in November 2026 for general information. Laws and court decisions can change after that date. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Authorities cited
Georgia code
- O.C.G.A. § 9-11-35
- O.C.G.A. § 9-11-37
- O.C.G.A. § 24-7-702
- O.C.G.A. § 24-8-826
Leave a Reply