Time-Limited Demands and Holt Demands in Georgia
Published 10 authorities named
A “Holt demand” in Georgia is an offer to settle within policy limits, with a deadline, that puts an insurer’s duty to its insured to the test. It takes its name from Southern General Insurance Co. v. Holt, 262 Ga. 267 (1992). Missing the deadline isn’t automatically bad faith, and the injured person doesn’t get a direct claim. The claim belongs to the insured, who may assign it after a judgment above limits. For motor vehicle claims, § 9-11-67.1 adds statutory terms on top.
What Holt said
The facts are worth knowing. Liability was clear, and a lawyer offered to settle for the $15,000 limit with a ten-day deadline, then extended it and supplied records. The insurer didn’t respond. A jury later awarded $82,000.
| Statement | Meaning |
|---|---|
| "An insurance company does not act in bad faith solely because it fails to accept a settlement offer within the deadline" | A deadline isn't a trap by itself |
| No rule that an insurer has "no duty to its insured to respond to a deadline" when it knows of "clear liability and special damages exceeding the policy limits" | Silence can be enough for a jury |
| Equal consideration | The insurer must give its insured's interests equal weight |
The right to punitive damages didn’t pass by assignment in that case, and a later decision, Empire Fire v. Driskell, 264 Ga. App. 646 (2003), says “the right to punitive damages cannot be assigned”.
What later decisions added
| Decision | Point | Who won |
|---|---|---|
| Cotton States v. Brightman, 276 Ga. 683 (2003) | Test is "the ordinarily prudent insurer"; a condition tied to another insurer doesn't excuse the first | Insured's side |
| Baker v. Huff, 323 Ga. App. 357 (2013) | Not "required to accept an offer which, under all the circumstances, imposes an unreasonably short period of time" | Insurer |
| First Acceptance v. Hughes, 305 Ga. 489 (2019) | Duty "arises only when the injured party presents a valid offer to settle within the insured's policy limits" | Insurer |
| GEICO v. Whiteside, 311 Ga. 346 (2021) | Insured's failure to forward suit papers doesn't by itself relieve the insurer; causation for a jury | Insured's side |
| Cannon v. Safeco, A25A1847 (2026) | Interpleading limits without a demand can be a jury issue, at the pleading stage | Insured's side |
First Acceptance v. Hughes is a warning for drafters. Letters in that case had no acceptance deadline, and the offer was treated as open for a reasonable time. The insurer didn’t act unreasonably in not accepting before it was withdrawn. So say plainly that it’s an offer, what the terms are, and when it ends.
Cannon v. Safeco says Hughes didn’t answer every question. An insurer’s conduct before any demand can matter, at least at the dismissal stage.
What a demand needs
| Element | Reason | Drafting point |
|---|---|---|
| Valid offer | Hughes | Clear words of offer |
| Within limits | Hughes; Holt | Find the limits first |
| Who gets released | Insured needs protection | Name each insured |
| Time | Baker | Fit the time to the information given |
| Information | Holt; Baker | Records with the letter |
| Liens | The insurer may ask | Say how they'll be handled |
| Acceptance method | Avoid a dispute | State exactly how |
| Other claimants | Limited limits | Competing claims need their own plan |
The overview of car accident claims puts competing claims in context. No statute sets a time for a common-law demand, and no case gives a safe number of days. In Holt, ten days with an extension went to a jury. In Baker, ten days with medical information cut off didn’t. The question is reasonableness on the facts. A longer period on a complete file is harder to attack.
Vehicle claims: § 9-11-67.1
If a lawyer prepares a pre-answer offer on a motor vehicle tort claim, the statute’s terms apply, including a time for acceptance and the 2024 changes. See § 9-11-67.1. That page is the place for acceptance rules and the safe harbor. Claims that don’t arise from a vehicle, such as a premises or product case, remain under the Holt line.
The path from demand to recovery
- The demand expires.
- Suit is filed against the insured, not the insurer.
- A judgment exceeds limits. Without excess exposure, the failure may cause no damage.
- The insured assigns the claim or sues directly.
- The second suit asks whether the insurer acted reasonably.
- The insurer defends with what it knew when the deadline ran.
That takes years, and it doesn’t guarantee recovery. GEICO v. Whiteside, as Cannon quotes it, says the insured can sue “only when the insurer had a duty to settle the case, breached that duty, and its breach proximately caused damage to the insured beyond the damages, if any, contemplated by the insurance contract”. So weigh a limits settlement against the long route.
Statutes people confuse
| Statute | Covers | Doesn't cover |
|---|---|---|
| § 33-4-6 | An insurer's bad-faith refusal to pay its own insured's covered loss | A third party's injury claim |
| § 33-4-7 | Loss "because of injury to or destruction of property" under a motor vehicle liability policy | Bodily injury |
| § 9-11-67.1 | Lawyer-prepared pre-answer vehicle offers | A non-vehicle case |
| Holt line | Failure to settle within limits | First-party penalties |
Insurance bad faith goes through them.
Duties of the lawyer and the insured
A lawyer must deal with a represented insured through counsel. An insured who gets a demand letter should send it to the insurer at once. In Whiteside, the insured discarded suit papers, and a default judgment for millions followed. Whether that excused the insurer was a jury question, but it put everything at risk. So tell your insurer in writing, and ask in writing that it settle within limits.
Sources
- Southern General v. Holt, 262 Ga. 267
- Empire Fire v. Driskell, 264 Ga. App. 646
- Cotton States v. Brightman, 276 Ga. 683
- Baker v. Huff, 323 Ga. App. 357
- First Acceptance v. Hughes, 305 Ga. 489
- GEICO v. Whiteside, 311 Ga. 346
- Cannon v. Safeco, A25A1847
- Official Code of Georgia Annotated, November 2022 public release: §§ 9-11-67.1, 33-4-6, 33-4-7
This page was last reviewed in November 2026 for general information. Laws and court decisions can change after that date. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Authorities cited
Georgia code
- O.C.G.A. § 9-11-67.1
- O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6
- O.C.G.A. § 33-4-7
Court decisions
- Southern General v. Holt, 262 Ga. 267
- Empire Fire v. Driskell, 264 Ga. App. 646
- Cotton States v. Brightman, 276 Ga. 683
- Baker v. Huff, 323 Ga. App. 357
- First Acceptance v. Hughes, 305 Ga. 489
- GEICO v. Whiteside, 311 Ga. 346
- Cannon v. Safeco, A25A1847
Leave a Reply