Skip to the articles
Attorney Directory

Georgia’s One Bite Rule

Published 6 authorities named

Georgia does not give every dog one free bite. The phrase refers to the requirement that an owner knew the dog was dangerous, and the Supreme Court of Georgia has called the “first bite rule” label “more than a bit misleading”. A plaintiff can win with no earlier bite, and can lose after one. The test is whether the owner had reason to know the dog might do the kind of harm it did.

What the Supreme Court said about the label

Steagald v. Eason, 300 Ga. 717 (2017), is the controlling discussion. The court wrote that, to the extent the term implies knowledge cannot be proved “unless and until the dog actually has bitten someone”, it is misleading. It quoted an earlier Court of Appeals decision that the rule “does not literally require a first bite”. What is required is “reason to know of [the dog’s] propensity to do harm of the type which it inflicts”.

Winning without an earlier bite

The Steagald facts show how. A pit bull named Rocks had snapped at two people, about a week before biting the plaintiff, and one of the dog’s keepers knew it. The Court of Appeals had called those incidents “merely menacing behavior”. The Supreme Court reversed, because a jury could view a snap as an attempted bite. The opinion leaves this to a jury. It does not hold that every snap proves knowledge.

An owner’s own words can also count. In the cases collected in how Georgia courts read vicious propensity, statements showing the owner expected trouble have been enough to reach a jury.

Losing after an earlier incident

Steagald also limits the plaintiff. An earlier bite “in highly unusual circumstances” may not prove knowledge of a propensity to bite elsewhere. And the “of the type” language means an owner who knew of one kind of harm may not be charged with knowing of a very different one. Torrance v. Brennan adds the balance on the other side, since the earlier incident need not match exactly. How Georgia courts read vicious propensity sets the outcomes side by side.

What does not count by itself

Steagald reviews decisions saying that barking and growling at people, “without more”, will not create a jury issue on notice of a propensity to attack. Swanson v. Tackling, 335 Ga. App. 810 (2016), reversed the denial of summary judgment where a dog barked and put its head through a door, and nothing showed that it had ever bitten or tried to bite anyone. Kringle v. Elliott, 301 Ga. App. 1 (2009), called some of the evidence about a dog’s conduct “speculative at best”.

A recent case that shows the two sides

Cornejo v. Allen (Ga. Ct. App. 2023) has a split result. The dog bit Cornejo one day, in the owner’s presence, and charged him the next day, when he slipped and fell while running. The court affirmed summary judgment on strict liability and reversed it on negligence. The earlier bite “may be sufficient to put Allen on notice that the dog might again try to attack Cornejo”, even though the second event ended with a fall and not a bite. The court recognized that a jury could still see the two events differently.

Why the phrase persists, and when the rule does not apply

The phrase survives because a known prior bite is the plainest evidence of knowledge. Two other routes do not depend on it. A local restraint ordinance gives a separate way to prove the required elements, described on the leash law page. And the knowledge rule itself concerns owners and keepers: other defendants, like landlords, have their own test.

How to read the facts of a case

Three questions replace the slogan: What had the dog done before? Who knew about it, and is there proof they knew? How close is that earlier conduct to what happened here? An answer that says “bit someone last week, in front of the owner” is different from “growled at a jogger”. Where the answer to the first two questions is nothing, the ordinance route is the remaining path.

Sources

This page was last reviewed in November 2026 for general information. Laws and court decisions can change after that date. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Authorities cited

Georgia code

  • O.C.G.A. § 51-2-7

Court decisions

  • Steagald v. Eason, 300 Ga. 717
  • Torrance v. Brennan, 209 Ga. App. 65
  • Swanson v. Tackling, 335 Ga. App. 810
  • Kringle v. Elliott, 301 Ga. App. 1
  • Cornejo v. Allen (Ga. Ct. App. 2023)

Every source, with its link

Reader comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *